- The price of a kidney is EUR 15,000 and of a lung EUR 40,000. The newspapers have come to shocking findings when two journalists negotiated at the black market the purchase of human organs for ill aunt.
How much is a kidney in Dubai?
In the UAE, a kidney transplant costs Dh100,000 to Dh150,000.
Can I sell a kidney in Dubai?
The Gulf state now allows organ transplantation from both the living and deceased. Under Federal Decree No. However, the law prohibits the “sale” of human organs and tissues, bans unlicensed advertising of transplants as well as funding transplantation if the organs are sold.
Do kidney donors get money?
Paying living kidney donors $10,000 to give up their organs would save money over the current system based solely on altruism — even if it only boosts donations by a conservative 5 percent. We don’t have enough organ donors coming forward,” said Dr.
What is the cost of donating a kidney?
6 Lakh in private hospitals of the country. And post-treatment, the monthly cost is around Rs. 15,000 with the lifelong medicines costing around Rs. 10,000 per month.
Is it legal to sell organs in UAE?
The Decree Law prohibits the sale of human organs and tissues or other body parts in any way for the purpose of transplantation. It also bans unlicensed advertising of transplantation of human organs, tissues and body parts. Living donors must be legally competent persons.
Is donating kidney legal?
The Government of India had passed the law ‘The Human Organ Transplantation Act, 1994’ in order to regulate the removal, storage, and transplantation of human organs for therapeutic purposes and to prevent commercial dealing in human organs. The rules clearly define who can donate organs.
Can I donate my organs after death?
The organ donor can play a big role in saving others’ life. Tissues such as cornea, heart valves, skin, and bone can be donated in case of natural death but vital organs such as heart, liver, kidneys, intestines, lungs, and pancreas can be donated only in the case of ‘brain death’.
Can you live without a kidney?
Technically, people can live with no kidneys, but require dialysis. Spleen: The spleen filters blood and helps the body fight infections, but it’s not essential for survival. The spleen can be removed if, for instance, it’s damaged. However, people without a spleen are more prone to infections.
Can I live with one kidney?
There may also be a chance of having high blood pressure later in life. However, the loss in kidney function is usually very mild, and life span is normal. Most people with one kidney live healthy, normal lives with few problems. In other words, one healthy kidney can work as well as two.
Hospital urgently needs kidney donors
The Dubai Hospital is in desperate need of kidney donors for 25 children who, unless they receive kidney transplants, would be on dialysis for the rest of their lives. Another 100 patients, ranging in age from one day to fourteen years, are presently having treatment at the hospital, which is operated by the Dubai Department of Health and Medical Services, for varying stages of renal failure, according to the facility’s website. Dr. Mazen Abou-Chaaben, the hospital’s chief of paediatrics, stated that the facility has the capability to undertake the transplant surgeries, but that there is a severe scarcity of willing donors.
The contributors, on the other hand, are in short supply.” He found that there is a general lack of understanding regarding the repercussions of organ transplantation among the general populace.
There are two types of organ transplants: one that uses organs from a deceased donor, and the other that uses organs from a living donor.
“As a result, parents can make donations on behalf of their children, as well as their siblings and first cousins.
According to him, “it is not acceptable for anyone to purchase kidneys from impoverished people who are selling their organs for money.” “If we get enough donations, we will be able to put a stop to this type of malpractice.” Because of considerable public knowledge, the transplant programs in Bahrain, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia are more effective than in other Middle Eastern countries.
- He went on to explain that 25 children are now in need of a kidney transplant at the hospital since they are in the third stage of renal failure.
- Patients may carry on with their lives throughout the early stages of the disease, and there are no evident issues “Dr.
- He said that the second stage necessitates the administration of medicine to the patient and is characterized by symptoms such as anemia, tiredness, lack of appetite, growth retardation, and a general feeling of ill health.
- “Patients who are in the fourth or final phase of their disease have reached the end of their treatment options and are in need of a transplant.
- Abou-Chaaben made the observation.
Our patients’ quality of life is improved if they are placed on dialysis during the third phase of therapy; yet, we have no alternative.” He stated that the number of children suffering from kidney failure in the United Arab Emirates is significant, with consanguineous marriages being regarded as one of the primary causes.
Furthermore, medical care has progressed to such an extent that babies who would have perished at birth in the past are now able to survive.
“These infants have suffered from a lack of oxygen flow and other sorts of trauma at birth, or they have extremely weak internal systems, and they also have a high incidence of renal issues,” he continued.
A kidney costs $100,000. The donor gets $2,000
In the early afternoon of two days ago, at precisely 4 p.m., a man from Gloucester named Andy posted on the bulletin board of an American-based website the following message. “I am a 22-year-old guy in good health who is interested in selling a kidney and perhaps some liver tissue. I would want further information, such as how much they are worth.” Tash, who is also British, responded 34 minutes later with the following message: “I’m willing to sell one of my kidneys. I am a 27-year-old woman in good health.
- “I already posted a notice about selling organs, and I’d want to receive bids for a half liver, a kidney, or a testicle.” In the last month, more than 30 people have contacted the website, all of them are providing comparable services.
- Any human organ or tissue that can be usefully sliced from one person and sewn onto another is prohibited in this country, including hearts, lungs, kidneys, livers, pancreas and small bowel, corneas, bone marrow, skin and heart valves.
- Regardless of how ill you are, whatever your money, career, or celebrity status may be, it is not feasible in our nation to get ahead of the line.
- The affluent unwell, on the other hand, are increasingly demonstrating that they are reluctant to wait – and are even willing to break the law in the name of saving a life-saving organ.
- Increased demand, coupled with a decrease in supply, results in a thriving market for individuals willing to pay to bypass the queues.
- So, how much does it cost to procure some delectable human offal for one’s own consumption?
According to a study conducted earlier this year by the Council of Europe, the going rate for a kidney transplant from eastern Europe is USD$100-200,000 (£58,000 – £116,000), with donors, who are typically young, male Moldovans or Romanians “between 18 and 28 years of age living in poor conditions in rural parts of the country,” receiving $2,500 (£1,400).
- According to an American Medical Association survey conducted in 2002, 305 kidney donors in Chennai, India, were paid just $1,070 (£620) apiece, with 96 percent of those surveyed claiming they were coerced into the donation because of poverty.
- The business that has come to be known as “transplant tourism” began to grow in the 1980s, when rich Asians began traveling to India and south-east Asia in order to purchase organs for themselves.
- For example, Middle-Eastern Arabs, for example, are known to have preferred India.
- Many years have passed since there were suspicions of organ harvesting from executed Chinese inmates, and some proof exists that China has ties to the United States market.
- In his own experience, he has come across “a considerable number” of people who have purchased kidneys from other countries, generally for “hundreds of thousands” of dollars.
- “I’ve heard of incidents when the patient received the transplant and was then whisked away in a cab and on a plane, with only the bare minimum of medications, to return home.
- In spite of the fact that it is feasible to give a portion of one’s liver – and, in extremely rare situations, a chunk of the lung – while one is still alive, Hakim claims that the only significant pay for organ market is for kidneys.
(According to a representative for Transplant UK, which oversees the British transplant database, testicles, which are given in large quantities and with a lot of excitement on the website on which Andy is advertising, are not yet known to perform a beneficial transplantable role.
According to a French non-governmental organization (NGO), Terre des Hommes, 6,000 minors between the ages of 12 and 16 are trafficked into western Europe each year, primarily from eastern Europe.
We are aware that gangs sell children, either dead or alive, to unsuspecting parents.
Thor Andersen, a property billionaire living in London, paid £25,000 to go to Pakistan and purchase a kidney from a 22-year-old lady in March of this year.
I needed to get my life back, and the girl needed money.” Instead of feeling angry at what he had done, Andersen advocated subsequently that all Britons should be automatically included to a transplant registry from which they might choose to opt out of participation.
“Then people wouldn’t have to witness affluent individuals like me who have traveled to an impoverished nation in order to acquire a kidney,” says the author.
Dubai debtor willing to put kidney up for sale to pay off Dh90,000
DUBAI / The capital of the United Arab Emirates. A debtor who owes Dh90,000 but is unable to pay it has stated that he will sell one of his kidneys in order to escape going to prison. In a statement released yesterday, the individual who goes by the name Mohammed stated, “This is not something I want to do but it is the only way out.” He claims that his financial difficulties began two years ago when he took out a bank loan to assist his brother in purchasing a bus. A year and a half later, his brother was killed in a car accident, and the automobile was declared totaled.
- Although it is the only option, “this is something I do not want to do,” she says.
- I have a responsibility to his family as well as mine.
- “Because we don’t have a home, my family and I are constantly on the go.” Selling or trafficking of organs is a criminal offense, however an advertising for a kidney was posted on the classifieds website Dubizzle in January by someone attempting to sell a kidney.
- “Even promoting this is unethical,” says Mohammed Al Zaabi, a liver transplant doctor at Zayed Military Hospital.
- It is completely banned, and anyone caught doing so would be subjected to harsh punishment.” Organ donation is subject to stringent regulations.
- As a result, there is a significant waiting list for organ transplants among those who need them.
- Al Zaabi, however not all of them required a kidney transplant.
According to him, the number of persons who do this is enormous.
Typically, they are carried out on the black market in less than ideal settings.
The doctor said that if they have an infection due to an infected kidney and their immune system has been weakened, “they would almost certainly contract a major illness and die.” The United Arab Emirates is working on a bill that will allow for organ transplants from deceased donors.
Doctor Al Obaidli stated that when something is not permitted in this nation, “we must provide people with viable alternatives.” Dr.
“Removing an organ from someone who is still alive is never a harmless procedure,” Dr.
“Every day, there are a large number of individuals who die, and their precious organs are buried with them, where they are of no service to anyone,” he explained.
“I have to make an effort to do something for the kids.” “I don’t want any difficulties, and I don’t want to cause any issues.” “I don’t want to cause any trouble, or to cause any problems.” My family will be wrecked if I get into any sort of difficulty.
“It will be the end of the world for us.” Ramola Talwar Badam contributed additional reporting.
Which Organs Can I Live Without, And How Much Cash Can I Get For Them?
Photographers Victor de Schwanberg and Photo Researchers First and foremost, a disclaimer: In the United States, it is against the law to sell your organs. It’s also quite hazardous. Handing out an organ is dangerous enough when done at a prestigious hospital; it becomes even more dangerous when done in a back alley for cash. Please, don’t do it. I mean it. OK? OK. There are several organs that one might potentially do without, or for which there is a backup system in place. People can live a long life even when they have one kidney, a section of their liver, a lung, a portion of their intestines, and an eyeball spared.
And no one is going to earn a lot of money off of an eyeball.
“There is virtually no commercial demand for eyeballs,” says the author.
No one’s going to make much cash on an eyeball.
As previously stated, black-market organ sellers do a poor job of filing taxes, but the following are some estimated costs based on rumors of transactions and reports from the World Health Organization. A kidney is worth around $20,000 in India. Buyers in China are willing to pay up to $40,000 or more. A decent, healthy kidney sourced from Israel may be purchased for $160,000. Don’t expect to walk away with all of that money, though. In legal and illicit organ-donor operations, “the individual who gives up the organ barely gets a fraction of the amount,” says Sally Satel, a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute think tank who investigates the rates paid by legal and illegal organ-donor organizations.
The majority of people receive between $1,000 and $10,000 for their kidney (probably much less than you were hoping for).
The best course of action is to wait until compensation for organs is legalized in the United States—the Organ Trafficking Prohibition Act of 2009, which would have allowed payment to donors, but which has been stalled in Congress—because there is unquestionably a market for kidneys in the United States of America.
And it’s likely that you could hold out for much more. Before eBay delisted a kidney that had been placed up for sale in 1999, buyers brought the price up to $5.75 million, according to records. The original version of this story appeared in the February 2010 edition of Popular Science magazine.
Sell a Kidney – Review of Burj Al Arab, Dubai, United Arab Emirates – Tripadvisor
This was our second stay at the Burj Al Arab, and we were not disappointed. There isn’t another hotel just like it anywhere else in the world. The only issue we had was that we were staying at both the Burj and the Al Qasr for two nights each. We attempted to book via Jumeirah bookings, but they were a total nightmare, never responding to our emails, and we ultimately had to go through both hotels to resolve the issue. Also, we particularly appreciated the extra attention you received when you arrived at the airport and were welcomed by a representative from the aircraft.
- When it came to getting our complimentary red wine changed to white, our Butler, though cheerful and extremely helpful, did not have a strong command of the English language.
- We also encountered problems with our entertainment equipment and our bathroom one night, which were fortunately resolved quickly, but required us to spend a considerable amount of time waiting around, which should have been verified beforehand.
- However, other from these little annoyances, we had a lovely experience that was far too short.
- Excellent breakfasts served by really pleasant employees, as well as thoughtful extras.
- Even after all these years, we still enjoy the Sahn Eddar – this little oasis of calm is one of our favorite places to unwind with a cup of tea or a cocktail while receiving excellent service.
- This time around, our experience at the Sky View Bar was less than satisfactory.
- The cocktails were alright, and the food was alright as well.
- We were sad to say goodbye to the Burj; it is truly a hotel that we adore and that holds a special place in both of our hearts.
- So, if you’re thinking about making a reservation, go ahead and do it because there isn’t anything else quite like it.
Cash for kidneys
Many patients from the Gulf States, who are suffering from diabetes, are being forced to fly to Egypt in search of organs from desperate donors, as the need for kidney transplants continues to rise. Dr. Mustafa Ahmed has seen the raw, curving scar that runs from his patients’ hipbone to their pelvis more times than he can count on his fingers and fingers alone. It was left by a kidney transplant procedure – not one that he himself had carried out – and it is visible. His work involves cleaning up the mess left by botched operations carried out in foreign countries and brokered by middlemen who assist in matching desperate donors with prospective transplant patients.
- Approximately 150 patients from the Gulf states come to Egypt each year, according to regional doctors, to undergo illicit transplant surgery.
- Because it is unlawful for foreign patients to undergo transplantation in the nation, many of them have their information faked by the clinics where they are treated.
- Region-wide nephrologists and officials from Egypt’s Ministry of Health have both verified that a number of institutions in the country had fabricated medical records.
- Sadiq Abdulla, a consultant vascular and renal transplant surgeon at Salmaniya Medical Complex in Bahrain, “reports are templated; there is no name of the patient, hospital, doctor, or institute.
- So far, four physicians have been laid off from their positions.
- Approximately 150 patients from the Gulf states come to Egypt each year, according to regional doctors, to undergo illicit transplant surgery.
According to Dr Abdulla, “because other nations, such as the Philippines and Pakistan, have closed their doors, there have been a slew of other countries that have recognized this as a wonderful chance to cash in on patients.” This year, he has seen eight patients who have been hospitalized to his hospital as a result of difficulties after transplant surgery that was performed in Egypt.
- The agents, who transport victims to unknown hospitals where they are treated by unknown doctors, are believed to be the means by which this is accomplished.
- According to Dr Faisal Shaheen, director general of the Saudi Center for Organ Transplants (SCOT), the kingdom currently has approximately 11,000 people on dialysis, with diabetes accounting for 25 percent of the total.
- Many patients in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) are being forced to turn to the black market for organs since there are no established cadaveric programs that allow for the donation of kidneys from the deceased.
- However, while SCOT is well-known for its efforts to encourage dead donors, the availability of organs in many other Gulf states is limited due to a lack of equivalent programs.
- An international treaty signed in May by 78 nations called for an end to organ trafficking and transplant tourism, and also called for a worldwide ban on organ trafficking and transplant tourism.
- Despite Egypt’s support for the document as well as legislation prohibiting transplants between foreigners, the practice continues to be practiced there.
- “However, it happens virtually every day,” Delmonico says.
- According to Dr.
- “We have patients who have recently returned from Egypt with new transplants.
- The patients don’t pay attention to what we say.
- One of the 13 patients who flew from Kuwait this year has already passed away, and several others have experienced difficulties as a result of their procedure.
In Dr Ahmed’s opinion, “the individuals who sell kidneys are among the lowest of the poor; they are infested with illnesses, and they are selling their kidneys because they are desperate for money, thus it is inevitable that those who get the kidneys would also contract infections.” According to the World Health Organization, 66,000 kidney transplants were conducted worldwide in 2005.
- According to the Egyptian Ministry of Health’s investigations, both doctors and hospitals have benefited financially from these treatments in Egypt.
- “The primary physician is a nephrologist, who oversees the entire operation and pays everyone else.
- As Maghraby says, “per capita, these hospitals make 15,000 Egyptian pounds ($2700) in revenue.” “These patients used to travel to India.
- A kidney may be purchased easily in Egypt thanks to the efforts of brokers who prey on urology institutions, dialysis centers, and websites.
- However, this is one commodities sale that nephrologists would like not see go place.
- Diabetes is a major problem in the United Arab Emirates.
- The declaration of Istanbul, as well as the subsequent tightening of organ circles, made it normal practice for insurance companies to transfer patients overseas to undergo organ transplants before the declaration.
“I’m not sure if the ministry of health is making money, but it’s possible that they are saving money on their health-care budget,” Noel speculates.
The fax informed hospitals of a change in Philippine law that would prevent UAE patients from receiving kidney transplants in the country.
Iran is the only country that allows the sale of organs.
Since then, there has been a rift in the country over whether or not the country should reconsider its prohibition on organ trading.
As a result, the country boasts the greatest percentage of live donors in the world, with just a small number of people traveling overseas for transplants.
Iranian law requires that a patient seeking a kidney first look for a suitable donor within their own family, failing which they must wait up to six months for a suitable deceased donor.
Donors can choose between two types of compensation: a set $1200 charge plus one year of free health insurance from the government, as well as a lump sum payment from the recipient, or a donation of between $2300 and $4500 from a specified charity.
The Iranian payment system, on the other hand, is frequently criticized for having a detrimental influence on dead contribution, which is almost non-existent in the country.
According to Dr Francis Delmonico, head of Medical Affairs at The Transplantation Society, “it is a lie to imply that the market is controlled because there is no set payment.” “I do not consider the Iranian model to be an exemplary one in terms of international standards or ethical practice,” says the author.
LINK TO ANOTHER SITE: Organ Failure Follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn, like us on Facebook, and subscribe to ourYouTube channel, which is updated daily, for the latest business news from the UAE and Gulf nations.
Need a kidney? Inside the world’s biggest organ market
Chennai, India – The city of Chennai is the capital of Tamil Nadu. Three years ago, Vikas was a school dropout working on his father’s farm in the northern Indian city of Kanpur, a job he disliked and wished he could avoid. However, things have turned around for him today. The 26-year-old is earning far more money as one of the hundreds of kidney brokers operating throughout the Indian subcontinent, helping to feed an ever-expanding multimillion-dollar illegal market for the highly sought-after organ of human origin.
Within a month, I will locate you a donor, and you will be able to return home with a brand new kidney.
As reported by the World Health Organization (WHO), South Asia has surpassed Europe as the main transplant tourism destination in the world, with India being among the top kidney exporters.
IN CONNECTION WITH: Arrests made in the China kidney-for-iPhone case An agent based in Mumbai who requested anonymity to avoid police retaliation said “his kidneys” have been donated to recipients in countries as diverse as Canada, Israel, the United Kingdom, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, though he noted that more and more buyers were now coming from within India.
A combination of the nearly universal prohibition on the sale of human organs and the widespread unwillingness in many cultures to donate kidneys even after death means that patients often have to spend years hooked up to dialysis machines – unless they can find an organ donor who will donate their kidneys to them.
However, in recent years, Colombo, the capital of Sri Lanka, has emerged as the new nerve center of this network, serving as the site of the majority of transplant surgeries.
Following the arrest of a “kidney kingpin” who was heading one of the world’s largest kidney trafficking gangs in 2008, India strengthened its laws on organ exchanges.
In an interview with Al Jazeera, Anurag, one of the most well-known names in the brokering industry, said that many agents in India and Bangladesh were working at the behest of individual doctors or hospitals based in Colombo, who offered “complete packages” to foreign recipients for prices ranging from $53,000 to $122,000.
- Because it saves everyone time and worry, this is the most efficient method,” Anurag – who also requested that his actual name be suppressed to prevent complications – told Al Jazeera from Sri Lanka.
- The presence of brokers such as Vikas and Aadarsh on dozens of Facebook sites purporting to be kidney and transplant support groups is not a secret.
- The messages frequently appear to be made by a “distressed relative” who is in desperate need of a certain blood-match donor, implying that a rapid transaction is in order.
- “They always place greater faith in a young, attractive lady.
- In the past, I have also used English names to refer to people.
- However, there are a number of guidelines that must be followed when using social media.
- I avoid meeting new people unless I am certain that they are not a trap.
“You won’t be able to locate me in the next month,” Vikas said.
Those who already have passports will be given priority over others.
Those living in the country’s southwestern region are often referred to a major, private specialty hospital in the city of Chennai.
According to the doctor, “The laboratories transmit me the test results, but sometimes they send them directly to the physicians in Colombo.” The exams are being paid for by a person in Chennai.
“I prepare all of the necessary documentation, including the passport if one is required.
He generally arranges to meet them, sometimes for the first time, at the New Delhi railway station, where they board the train to Mumbai, where they will spend the night.
It has been directed to me that I drop them off at hotels or guesthouses at predetermined areas.
I’ve also left them off to ISD phone shops and then walked away without looking back, as instructed by the company.
“The donor would travel to Colombo with another agent in order to complete the process,” Vikas explained.
Last year, he completed eight transactions for a total of more than half a million rupees ($7,700).
Others who get their passports prepared by the brokers might paid up to 300,000 rupees ($4,500) for their efforts.
A beautiful apartment complex in Colombo, about a kilometer away from one of three clinics that openly cater to “foreign clientele,” is where both the donor and the broker generally stay. Donors often return home in 18-25 days, depending on their circumstances.
ARRESTED IN THE CASE OF THE CHINESE KIDNAPPED FOR AN IPHONE An agent based in Mumbai who requested anonymity to avoid police retaliation said “his kidneys” have been donated to recipients in countries as diverse as Canada, Israel, the United Kingdom, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, though he noted that more and more buyers were coming from within India. In response to an alarming increase in renal illnesses, diabetes, and high blood pressure, the global demand for kidneys has risen significantly, far outstripping supply.
What may be the world’s largest black market for organs is filling the gap between the demand for kidneys and the quantity of kidneys available legally.
However, in recent years, Colombo, the capital of Sri Lanka, has emerged as the new nerve center of this network, serving as the site of the majority of transplant surgeries.
This breakthrough arose after India tightened its laws on organ exchanges in 2008, following the arrest of a “kidney kingpin” who was leading one of the world’s largest kidney trafficking gangs at the time of the arrest.
In an interview with Al Jazeera, Anurag, one of the most well-known names in the brokering industry, revealed that many agents in India and Bangladesh were working at the behest of individual doctors or hospitals based in Colombo, who offered “complete packages” to foreign recipients for prices ranging from $53,000 to $122,000.
- The function of social media Despite the fact that the illicit trade has been thriving since the 1990s, social media has propelled it into a whole new realm.
- Once the broker has been notified of the need for a certain match, all it takes is a single post promising monetary compensation in return for a healthy kidney to get the match going in his favor.
- When Al Jazeera initially reached out to Vikas, he was posing as a young woman named Priyanka Singh on several online forums.
- At times, I’ve referred to people by their first and last names.
- However, there are a number of regulations to follow when using social media.
- In addition, I never react to those who have contacted me more than once in a single day.
- Men in their 20s or early 30s who are fit and non-smokers, according to the brokers, are the most sought after donors since they are more likely to go alone to other countries for organ donation.
The potential donor is then transported to one of many pathology facilities in New Delhi and Uttar Pradesh for pre-arranged blood tests as well as a tissue-typing test when confidence is established.
Certain doctors there are affiliated with the Colombo network, which aids in the speeding up of the procedure.
The tests are paid for by a person in Chennai.
On most occasions, he arranges to meet them at the New Delhi railway station, where they board the train to Mumbai, sometimes for the first time.
“I have been told to drop them off at specific hotels or guesthouses.” I constantly forget to take my money out of the ATM.
When I receive my commission, I never see or speak with the donor again.
While his first donor brought in 25,000 rupees ($380) three years ago, he now earns between 50,000 rupees ($757-$1,211) and 80,000 rupees ($1,211) each donor.
As reported by the brokers, donors who already have passports are compensated with around 400,000 rupees ($6,000), with a portion of the money being provided two days before the procedure takes place.
A beautiful apartment complex in Colombo, about a kilometer away from one of three hospitals that cater to “foreign clientele,” is where both the donor and the broker normally stay. Donors often return home in 18-25 days, depending on their situation.
Man falls for WhatsApp ad, tries to sell kidney for Dh800,000
Published:Monday, November 5, 2018, 9:03 a.m. The most recent update was made on Monday, November 5th, at 5:32 PM. It is fairly commonplace for fraudsters to create online friendships with people in order to trick them into disclosing their personal information or handing over money. An innocent guy was tricked into agreeing to sell his kidney for Rs1.6 crore in a fraud alleged in Bangalore, India, however this is a little too much for some people (Dh804,000 approx). The guy, who went by the name of MB Somashekar, was in desperate need of money when he fell prey to a scam advertising on the internet that offered a large sum in exchange for a kidney.
- He also claimed that the two had exchanged WhatsApp messages and spoken on the phone, during which Dr David, the hospital’s Director of Renal Transplant Surgery, promised him Rs1.6 crore in exchange for his kidney.
- He went to the hospital to continue the procedure, where he encountered a transplant coordinator called Aprajita Dhal, who advised him that the phone number used in the WhatsApp discussions did not belong to Dr David and that he should contact the hospital.
- An article published in a newspaper stated that “It is claimed that Dr David’s WhatsApp messages and subsequent chats on various dates were revealed to Dhal by Somashekar, who reportedly informed him that Dr David was in communication with him regarding the sale of his kidney.
- In response to the scammer’s actions, Dr David has filed a court complaint, and the Cyber Police have launched an inquiry into the incident.
Risks and Benefits of Living Kidney Donation
People who are considering becoming kidney donors must thoroughly assess the dangers and advantages of donating a kidney before making their decision. As discussed in further detail in this section, although the surgery itself is frequently a key component in this decision-making process, other aspects such as medical risks, the cosmetic outcome, and socioeconomic circumstances are also crucial considerations. The following is a detailed list of potential issues that may arise as a result of the kidney donation surgery: As assessed by the glomerular filtrate rate, the renal function of kidney donors frequently declines by 20 to 30 percent following donation.
Another set of issues that may arise in the long term following kidney donation surgery includes the following: Consideration of live donation may be a frightening and difficult experience for the potential donor.
The potential donor, on the other hand, is likely to experience worry and anxiety as a result of the likelihood of giving their organ, which will need their undergoing surgery themself.
Dedicated donor teams – which may include transplant coordinators, physicians, social workers, and psychiatrists – are well-versed in assisting potential donors in answering these questions for themselves and dealing with any challenges that may occur throughout the process.
Financial Aspects of Living Donation
It is important for those who are considering becoming kidney donors to thoroughly assess the dangers and advantages of doing so. However, although the surgery itself is frequently a key component of this choice, other variables such as medical risks, the cosmetic outcome, and socioeconomic concerns all play an essential part in the decision-making process, as detailed in further detail later in this chapter. Listed below is a detailed list of possible issues that may arise during or after kidney donation surgery.
- Using a procedure known as hyperfiltration, the remaining kidney compensates for the loss of one kidney.
- Depending on their situation, a possible donor can be concerned about their potential recipient or might be feeling guilty for the health issues that person is having.
- To their credit, most prospective donors have questions and worries that are quite similar to theirs.
- They are also trained to deal with any complications that could develop.
Usually, the insurance of the person who will be receiving your kidney (Medicare or private health insurance) will cover the testing necessary to determine whether or not you are a suitable donor (known as the evaluation process), as well as the surgery and hospitalization necessary for the kidney donation. A portion of post-operative follow-up treatment is often covered, but not all of it. The degree of covered follow-up care will vary based on the insurance coverage of your recipient.
Usually, the insurance of the person who will be receiving your kidney (Medicare or private health insurance) will cover the testing necessary to determine whether or not you are a suitable donor (known as the evaluation process), in addition to the surgery and hospitalization required for the kidney donation. Some post-operative treatment and follow-up is often covered, but not all. According on your recipient’s insurance policy, the scope of covered follow-up treatment will vary.
- Travel and hotel accommodations
- And elder care. Costs of follow-up (which vary depending on the situation
- See above)
- Loss of earnings (please note that in some situations, donors may be eligible for paid leave from their employers) (possible alternatives include sick leave, state disability, and the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA)
- Children’s and elder care, as well as travel and hotel accommodations Expenses associated with follow-up (see above)
- Lost earnings (please note that in some situations, donors may be eligible for paid leave from their employers) (possible possibilities include sick leave, state disability, and Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA)
Why Do Donors Need Health Insurance if the Recipient’s Insurance Pays for Everything?
Travel and hotel accommodations; child and elder care; Costs of follow-up (which vary, as shown above); Lost earnings (please note that in some situations, donors may be eligible for paid leave from their job) (possible possibilities include sick leave, state disability, and Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA);
Impact on Insurability
In rare situations, having been a kidney donor might have an influence on the donor’s ability to receive health insurance as well as life insurance in the future.
Because of this, it is strongly suggested that anyone considering donating seek this form of insurance before deciding on whether or not to donate.
In the state of New York, there is a $ 10,000 tax deduction for organ donation. Living donors can deduct up to $10,000 in donation-related expenditures from their state income taxes, including travel, housing, and missed wages. Visit the National Kidney Foundation’s Web site to learn more about tax deductions and credits available to live kidney donors.
Legal Issues Related to Payment for Donation
An exchange of “valuable consideration” for a human organ is expressly prohibited by the National Organ Transplantation Act of 1984. (“It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation”). As a result, it is against the law to sell organs; if this occurs, the offender will be subject to fines, imprisonment, or both. But under the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA), reimbursement of “the expenditures of travel, lodging, and lost earnings incurred by the donor of a human organ in connection with a human organ donation” is specifically authorized per Section 301 of the Act.
It is particularly prohibited by the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984 to trade a human organ for “consideration of significant value” (“It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation”). The sale of organs is, as a result, prohibited, and those who do so may face fines, imprisonment or both if they are found to have done so. Section 301 of the NOTA, on the other hand, clearly permits the reimbursement of “the expenditures of travel, lodging, and lost earnings incurred by the donor of a human organ in connection with the donation of the organ.” Find out more about the National Organ Transplantation Act by visiting their website (pdf).
Laparoendoscopic Single Site Donor Nephrectomy Scar
Currently, the current standard of treatment at NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell, which was a pioneering facility for this therapy, is
Laparoscopic Donor Nephrectomy Scar
The manner in which most facilities that do not yet conduct laparoendoscopic single site surgery execute donor surgery at the present time is described below.
Open Donor Nephrectomy Scar
Until the mid- to late-1990s, the technique in which donor surgery was conducted was considered standard practice.
Benefits of Kidney Donation
In many respects, the advantages of kidney donation are personal, and no one other than the individual who is giving or who has given will be aware of them. Various factors influence a donor’s decision to donate a kidney, and each individual has a unique experience throughout the process of giving a kidney, beginning with their decision to be examined as a possible donor and continuing for years after the donation has taken place. Various research studies have sought to measure the advantages and/or quality of life of kidney donors as a result of their donation, and the following information has been collated from such studies.
- If you compare kidney donors to the general population, they tend to have higher quality of life scores after donating their organs. An rise in the donor’s self-esteem as well as an elevated sense of well-being may be associated with this phenomenon. After donating, donors’ mental health is either the same as before or enhanced.
The extensive screening procedure that donors must go through has also assisted some potential donors with receiving diagnoses that might benefit from early intervention, like as cancers, which would have otherwise gone unnoticed. As a result of screening, some potential donors have had their own medical issues discovered early, such as kidney disease or high blood pressure or diabetes or cardiac disease.
These issues can be treated more effectively if discovered and treated quickly, as can be the case with kidney disease or high blood pressure.
The Big Ask, The Big Give
In most cases, the donor’s Medicare or private health insurance will cover the costs of the following for the receiver (if the donation is to a family member or friend). In the event that there are any exceptions, donors should always organize their testing with the transplant coordinator at the hospital:
- A screening process to assess whether or not the individual is a good candidate for live donation
- The procedure of organ donation
- The post-operative care
The following expenditures, on the other hand, are often not covered by either the recipient’s or the donor’s insurance policies:
- It is commonly accepted that neither the recipient’s insurance nor the donor’s insurance will cover the following expenses:
Click here to download a Cost-Estimate Worksheet for Living Organ Donation. Once again, potential donors should consult with the transplant center about their specific circumstances.
Will my health or life insurance coverage be affected by donation?
You should not be concerned about your health insurance being affected by your gift. A pre-existing condition is no longer grounds for denying coverage or charging you extra under the terms of the Affordable Care Act, which took effect in 2010. Some live donors, on the other hand, have reported having problems obtaining life insurance or having to pay higher rates for life insurance coverage. The transplant facility may be required to tell the insurance company of existing data indicating that the patient is not at elevated risk of mortality as a result of the donation in such situations.
You might also want to speak with an attorney who is well-versed in the field of insurance regulation.
It is critical for potential donors to thoroughly explore these factors before deciding to make a charitable contribution.
The insurance is optional for transplant facilities that participate in the Living Organ Donor Network data registration program, as well as for people who may desire to take advantage of the protection provided by this insurance.
Is there any assistance available for lost wages, travel and lodging?
There is a possibility that live donors could incur wage loss throughout their recuperation time, which can be a significant financial burden. Living donors are normally liable for any time missed from work, unless their employer is willing to give paid leave or allows the donor to take advantage of short-term disability insurance benefits.
During their recuperation period, some donors take use of a mix of vacation time, sick leave, and/or short-term disability benefits. The NKF recommends that you raise your concerns with the following individuals:
- Your transplant center’s financial counselor and/or social worker (if applicable)
- A department within your company’s Human Resources department
Depending on your circumstances, you may be eligible for assistance with travel and housing via the National Living Donor Assistance Program. People who desire to donate an organ but are unable to pay the travel and subsistence fees connected with living organ donation can apply for financial help through this program. Assistance with missed income to help cover bills such as mortgage or rent, electricity, car payment, or insurance may be available via the American Transplant Foundation if you meet the qualifications.
If a live donor gives at a Donor Shield Center affiliated with the National Kidney Registry (NKR), or if they are participating in an NKR swap between transplant facilities, they will be automatically eligible for Donor Shield Coverage under the program.
- Donors and their caregivers can receive up to $2,000 in reimbursement for lost wages for up to four weeks
- Travel, lodging, and mileage reimbursement for up to four weeks
- And other benefits. Life insurance with a main value of $500,000
- Disability insurance with a maximum weekly benefit of $1,500 for up to 52 weeks
- And long-term care insurance. Legal assistance
- Coverage for uninsured donor complication costs (which may be paid by the recipient’s insurance)
- Lost Wages and Travel Reimbursement for Donor Complications
- Priority for a living donor kidney transplant if and when one is required
Are there any laws related to taking time off to donate a kidney?
Those who work for the United States government Employees of the federal government are entitled to 30 days of paid leave for organ donation and 7 days of paid leave for bone marrow donation if they choose to make a donation. The leave is in addition to any sick or yearly leave that the employee may be entitled to. Those who work for the state governments Many states have begun to allow state employees up to 30 days leave (paid or unpaid) for participating in a living organ donation program, which is modeled after federal legislation (for federal employees).
Typically, the term of leave for organ donors is 30 days, while the period of leave for bone marrow donors is 7 days.
Employees in the private sector Eight states (Arkansas, Connecticut, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Minnesota, Nebraska, and Oregon) permit private sector employees to take a leave of absence for marrow (rather than organ) donation, however in many situations, this is only applicable to marrow donors rather than organ donors.
Are there tax deductions or credits available for living donors?
Many states have previously approved tax deductions or credits for living donors for expenditures incurred in connection with their gift that have not been repaid. For extensive state-by-state information, please see the following link. Existing federal legislation would allow living kidney, liver, lung, pancreas, intestine, and bone marrow donors to claim up to $5,000 in federal tax credits for unreimbursed expenditures (including lost income), if they donate their organs while still alive. Please provide your support in getting this legislation approved!
Make sure you respond to ALL of the notifications that have been highlighted.
Where can I get more information?
It is recommended that potential donors speak with their transplant facility regarding financial and insurance concerns. Transplant social workers and/or financial counselors will be available at the hospital to provide information to potential donors about their alternatives, as well as what fees would be borne by the recipient’s insurance, the donor, or the hospital. You can also obtain a free Q & A from the United Network for Organ Sharing titled “What Every Patient Needs to Know,” which is available online.
To obtain a copy, please contact UNOS at (888-894-6361). If you want to learn more about Living Donation and Employment or Living Donation and Insurability after Donation, you may also go to the Live Donor Financial Toolkit website by clicking here.